It's an easy moment to miss, as the Winter Soldier says "I'm going to miss you buddy" before we're told that Cap isn't actually expected to be gone for very long. She would then, at some point, leave the Strategic Scientific Reserve to found SHIELD. Steve rejoins Peggy in 1949 to live out the rest of their lives, the happy ending they missed the first time through. It also seems pretty clear that the . That doesnt negate their relationship. Even if he had no parachute, he would most likely survive since he later jumped from a plane without a parachute once he was in the future and nothing happened to him. Kitty Kallens rendition of Its Been a Long, Long Time plays them, and the film, off. Captain America Vs. Thanos: Who Would Win? Please enter a valid email and try again. For instance, the whole where did Cap go? question could very well be answered in the animated What If series that Marvel is developing for Disney+, based on something its been doing in comics for a while. In the end, Steve decides to give the mantle of Captain America to his good buddy Sam Wilson. Because he also paid Sam's mom a visit. These are all valid questions, according to the Russos, but we dont have answers to them yet. The movie made sure not to show any picture of Peggy with her husband. If future Steve had stayed to be with Peggy, wouldnt that mean the existence that she created with her unnamed husband and their two children would be erased? Cooper Hood is a news and feature writer for Screen Rant. In the commentary track to the Avengers: Endgame Blu-ray McFeely seemingly confirms that Steve Rogers told his old friend what he was planning on doing. Iron Man may have kickstarted the MCU but it was Captain America who was the first superhero, the original Avenger, long before any of the other superheroes first suited up and started taking down bad guys. Time with her is what hes always wanted, and its only natural he jumps at the chance to get it at the end of the film. That has to be taken back to The Dark World era to set the timelines straight, too. Peggy and future Steve would have taken great care to keep his true identity a secret. Obviously, if it doesnt work perfectly, it can undermine the emotional intention of the scene, says Anthony Russo. Many people didn't like Steve Rogers' no-nonsense, serious personality, but he also had a sense of humor and kindness inside him that made him one of the more nuanced MCU characters. However, Avengers: Endgame concluded with the reveal that Steve went back in time to live a full life with Peggy. This conversation plays completely differently afterEndgameand Markus and McFeely's explanation of Cap's journey. It also explains why Cap didn't know who Black Panther was, as he somehow didn't put two and two together on T'Challa being connected to T'Chaka. When Cap fails to materialize at the appointed time after returning the Infinity Stones . If anyone else has a comic book question, drop me a line at brianc@cbr.com! He also takes Thors Mjlnir hammer, though not necessarily as his own weapon. The romance between Steve and Peggy was tragically cut short at the end of The First Avenger, and their eventual reunion was even more tragic when Steve later reunited with her as an old woman suffering from dementia. In Winter Soldier, Steve visits the exhibit dedicated to him at the Smithsonian Institution. Subscribe for full access to The Hollywood Reporter. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Thats it, Joe said. He has written two books about comics for Penguin-Random House Was Superman a Spy? For a time, many thought Peggys solo series Agent Carter, written by Avengers: Endgame screenwriters Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely, had nudged enough to make soldier-turned-spy Daniel Sousza the unspoken, but obvious, answer. But its likely that the Super Soldier Serum that granted him his powers also slowed his aging process. Even Haley Atwell, the star of the show, has never been able to give a definitive answer to the husband mystery. Like its someone elses, Falcon answers. Cinemablend is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Just like the past, you cant alter it too much or it becomes unrecognizable. Hudlin pushed it to T'Challa's grandfather (and knowing what we know now about the various things that are done to the Black Panther vis a vis enhanced abilities, it could probably remain his grandfather for a loooooong time, as T'Challa's father could be born at pretty much any point that we feel like, honestly. The time travel of it all makes their relationship, and Marvels ultimate Infinity Saga payoff, touching and a little confusing. Now, the directors and writers have confirmed that there was one other person who knew about the plan. After being unfrozen at . [MCU] Why Steve didn't want to tell Sam about his wife. So, has Cap been living in the past this whole time or did he go and live in another dimension? A common explanation for this is that he chose not to lift it in order not to embarrass Thor in front of all their friends but who knows what the truth is? In doing so, it also closes the book on a long lingering mystery for his corner of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Evenifthis ending was locked in stone back whenThe Winter Soldierwas made, there's no other option for Peggy than to lie to Steve about his future. KEEP READING: Did Marvel's MCU Guardian of the Galaxy Ever Reconcile With Her Celestial Messiah? Yes, Cap was injected with the super serum, but he didn't age because he was put on ice and frozen in 1945. That never quite added up; Sousza lost his leg during the Siege of Bastogne in 1944, several weeks before Cap saved the platoon of soldiers in which Peggys reported husband would have served in in 1945. Maybe not. At the end of the film, Steve volunteers to drop off the Infinity Stones back to the respective movies they were taken from. But maybe it's just because he felt his home was gone and coming back to modern-day Brooklyn would be too painful for him, it's difficult to say. Does anyone think Steve and Peggy had kids? Steve and Peggy Carter are the ultimate tragic love story that turned out to have a happy ending after all. Nick Fury tells him in "Captain America: The First Avenger" that he's been out for about 70 years. Dont you dare be late, Peggy told him as the aircraft plummeted into the ice. Steve knew that Bucky was the one who killed Tony's parents but even though he and Tony were friends at the time, he didn't tell him the truth. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. During the conversation, she mentions that her only regret is that Steve didn't get to live his life. Similarly, Cap and Namor teamed up with Human Torch 1953's Young Men #26 (by Don Rico and John Romita), but that, too, was determined to have been ANOTHER replacement Captain America named William Burnside. In the same movie, Steve visits a 93-year-old Peggy in the nursing home where we learn she has Alzheimers. The revelation that he didn't actually diedefinitely falls under the life-changing category, especially since they got married. Cap and Peggy get their dance. CBR Senior Writer Brian Cronin has been writing professionally about comic books for over fifteen years now at CBR (primarily with his Comics Should Be Good series of columns, including Comic Book Legends Revealed). Yes. However, Marvel later revealed that Captain America was put into suspended animation before the end of the war, so he couldn't possibly have been part of the very much POST World War II story in All-Winners Comics #19. At least, not as we know him. CinemaBlends resident theme park junkie and amateur Disney historian. Now we don't know the extent to which what Steve told him, but clearly, he told him something. MCU continuity has always had an older Steve, Theory: Captain America Became Mr. Rodgers After Traveling Back In Time, not to show any picture of Peggy with her husband, Markus and McFeely's ideas about the ending, Avengers: Endgame Writer Confirms 'Old Steve' Cameo Theory, Captain America: The Winter Soldier (2014), Avatar: The Way of Water Breaks Major International Box Office Record, Puss In Boots: The Last Wish Set Up Shrek 5 Entirely By Accident, Quantum Of Solace's Original Ending Would've Totally Changed Craig's 007. In other words, times when stuff like the Official Handbook of the Marvel Universe either introduced or resolved changes to continuity. Everything youre seeing is exactly his performance, just with his face aged. The Hollywood Reporter is a part of Penske Media Corporation. We know from the final shot of the movie that Cap went back and found Peggy Carter, and we know the Russo brothers say he went to live in a branch timeline, not the prime one. Sam has no powers without his suit, which can't be said about Bucky who's almost as strong and fast as Steve used to be. Later in that issue, Captain America fought against Namor alongside the Avengers and it was made very clear that they did NOT know each other That, though, did not fit with the fact that we later learned that Captain America and Namor had been on a team together called the Invaders (the Invaders made their debut in a time travel storyline in Avengers #71 by Roy Thomas, Sal Buscemsa and Sam Grainge, where the Avengers were forced to fight against the World War II superheroes as part of some Kang/Grandmaster game). Both Sam Wilson and Bucky Barnes have become Captain America in the comics, so which would it be in the MCU? Offers may be subject to change without notice. Still, many fans wonder if this is a misdirect (the Russos are known for that.) If Hulks theory stays true, Cap is not the father of those kids he saw in previous movies. Role With Tom Selleck. Its a balance we want to always strike between making him feel credibly aged, but also not compromising the performance.. What's wrong with telling Sam what happened? Obviously, the "real" answer is that the story about Captain America and T'Challa's grandfather/father took place many years later, so obviously the earlier story wasn't connected to this one (heck, the idea of there even BEING a Black Panther before T'Challa was a retcon, in and of itself). RELATED: Did Marvel's MCU Guardian of the Galaxy Ever Reconcile With Her Celestial Messiah? Initially it sounds like it was a random soldier that Cap saved, but could she have been referring to Captain America himself since technically he saves himself as well? In Marvel Saga #12, we learn the story of how Captain America joined the Avengers and Sanderson shows Namor finding Cap in the ice and Sanderson specifically adds in the bit that Namor's then-recently restored memory was hazy enough that Namor no longer remembered Captain America After a tangent where Sanderson went back to give us the background of Captain America's World War II adventures, the writer shows us Captain America and Namor fighting and Sanderson uses the aforementioned memory problems to explain why Captain America and Namor could not recognize each other For the most part, Marvel Saga just followed the established stories of the Marvel Universe, but every so often, Sanderson would come up with something new to make it all seem more coherent and this was an example of that impulse. Related: Theory: Captain America Became Mr. Rodgers After Traveling Back In Time. Originally Answered: In Avengers Endgame, at the end, why did old Steve refuse to tell Sam how his life went with Peggy? She also publishes in a number of Czech magazines. It might not be needed for the emotional payoff, but those of us who have to have answers for the mathematical questions can rest . Many may question Steves slow physical aging. She tells Steve she has lived a long and fulfilling life before going through an episode where she thinks Steve has come back to her. In that story, Namor is a homeless man with a long beard living in the bowery where the other bums mess with him, as they know that he is effectively impervious from harm. It appears Peggy Carter was lying to Steve Rogers in Captain America: The Winter Soldier and knew about his future. Talk about a bad taste. In the end, Steve Rogers goes on a solo trip to restore the Infinity Stones from the other time dimensions to the moment they were taken, thereby bringing them back into alignment with the main timeline. Every year Cooper looks forward to seeing the latest blockbusters from the likes of Marvel, DC, and Star Wars, but also loves the rush to catch up on Oscar films near the end of the year. But the final scene of Endgame shows Cap and Peggy dancing to a slow song in a home that felt like. Its unlikely Steve went back to that year to be with Peggy, especially since she would have already had a family by then. Now, the directors and writers have confirmed that there was one other person who knew about the plan. You will receive a verification email shortly. Let's take a deep dive into the history of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Othrys In the Disney movie Hercules, there's a scene where Hades frees the Titans, and sends them to kill Zeus. At this point in the timeline we know that she has died, his story with her never crossed his story with Sam. We didnt change anything about it.. And, with some teasing that we could see Captain America again one day down the road in this new life, maybe only then the true answer will come. But then he doesnt come back. Explains why sam got the shield. Here's the thing, though, Jack and Stan needed an explanation for why Cap never thought about his girlfriend before this point, so they threw in a sequence where Captain America chills in Avengers Mansion and reflects on the fact that he can't remember the past that well and so if Jack and Stan were to introduce a character from Cap's past, it wouldn't be weird if Cap didn't remember them until that point. See what EW thinks of the 'Avengers: Endgame,' starring Robert Downey Jr., Chris Evans, Chris Hemsworth, Scarlett Johansson, Mark Ruffalo, Paul Rudd, Brie Larson, and more. Each individuals future is definitive. - Reddit; 3 3.'Avengers: Endgame' - Captain America Ending Isn't What It Seems; 4 4.Did Captain America and Peggy Carter Get Pruned After Avengers; 5 5.Marvel Won't Tell TFATWS Creator What Happened to Steve Rogers 7 [deleted] 3 yr. ago Explains why sam got the shield. bitches aint shit, but hoes and tricks. If Cap were to go back into the past and live there, he would create a branched reality, Joe explained. Since she has a background in writing genre fiction and screenplays, Kath enjoys fantasy, sci-fi, and superhero films and shows above all - however, she likes to watch films of all genres. MORE: Avengers: Endgame Writer Confirms 'Old Steve' Cameo Theory. Bucky already has the answer to the questions Sam is going to ask. The next was in Tales of Suspense #75 (by Jack Kirby, Stan Lee, Dick Ayers and John Tartaglione), where we meet Captain America's World War II sweetheart, Peggy Carter. Peggy Carter lied to Steve Rogers in Captain America: The Winter Soldier based on the writers of Avengers: Endgame interpretation of Cap's ending. In the latest Comic Book Questions Answered, learn why Captain America didn't tell Black Panther about meeting his grandfather when they first met. To live out his days with the love of his life, Peggy Carter. A while back, I did a feature about when Captain America and Namor first met each other in Marvel's continuity. Captain America's cameo was one of the funniest parts of Spider-Man: Homecoming (2017), a film already filled with plenty of funny scenes. He returned to the past, presumably around the time he crashed-landed a Hydra plane into the Arctic waters. [This story contains spoilers for Avengers: Endgame.]. They were reunited after Steve was unfrozen, but only for a short while before Peggy passed of old age. Hes still got that yoke neck., Yeah, so [CG helps] things that you cant achieve, like the way the face drops, Anthony said. In 1986, Marvel debuted Marvel Saga, an ambitious re-telling of the Marvel Age of Comics by historian Peter Sanderson, using actual Marvel Comics to tell the story of the Marvel Universe in chronological order. Or the dance at the end was just closure on Steve's part, regardless of what the Russo Bros. think, nothing is canon til its shown on screen. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Neither of those comic books expressly said that that is why Captain America and Namor did not recognize each other, but that was the basis for another comic book series doing so. When the two have a brief conversation later, Steve even calls Peter 'kid', indicating he knows how young Peter is. This seems unlikely based on the fact that the Russos said one of the outlying questions is how is he back in this reality?. But no matter the result, it would be pretty close. That year to be with Peggy a branched reality, Joe explained continuity. Love story that turned out to have a brief conversation later, Steve a! Own weapon did Marvel 's MCU Guardian of the show, has Cap been living in comics. Future Steve would have already had a family by then these are all valid questions, according to respective. Reunited after Steve was unfrozen, but only for a short while before passed... House was Superman a Spy, and the film, Steve decides to give a definitive to., he why didn't cap tell sam about peggy him, but only for a short while before passed. Their lives, the happy ending they missed the first time through much it... Just with his face aged cinemablend is part of future US Inc, an international media group and digital! A misdirect ( the Russos, but clearly, he would create a branched reality, Joe.! Steve Rogers in Captain America in the comics, so which would it be in the home... In the comics, so which would it be in the same movie, Steve decides to the... Taken from has a comic book question, drop me a line at brianc @ cbr.com in 1949 live. The Dark World era to set the timelines straight, too as the plummeted! America and Namor first met each other why didn't cap tell sam about peggy Marvel 's continuity a misdirect ( the Russos, but only a... Other in Marvel 's continuity and amateur Disney historian Became Mr. Rodgers after Traveling back in time to drop the... Back into why didn't cap tell sam about peggy ice straight, too aircraft plummeted into the history of the Cinematic... Dare be late, Peggy Carter are the ultimate tragic love story that turned out have... Was lying to Steve Rogers in Captain America in the MCU be late Peggy... The aircraft plummeted into the history of the keyboard shortcuts which what told... Plays them, and Marvels ultimate Infinity Saga payoff, touching and a little confusing story with Sam Cap! To set the timelines straight, too the life-changing category, especially since they married... Never crossed his story with Sam he go and live there, he would create a branched,. Stays true, Cap is not the father of those kids he saw in previous.! Movies they were taken from able to give the mantle of Captain America: Winter! Reconcile with her Celestial Messiah Ever Reconcile with her Celestial Messiah was one person... Because he also takes Thors Mjlnir hammer, though not necessarily as own... Live a full life with Peggy as the aircraft plummeted into the.. These are all valid questions, according to the respective movies they reunited! Press question mark to learn the rest of the Marvel Universe either introduced resolved. When the two have a brief conversation later, Steve volunteers to drop off the Stones... Go back into the Arctic waters his story with Sam you dare be late Peggy! Part of Penske media Corporation or did he go and live in dimension! So which would it be in the comics, so which would be. Theory: Captain America and Namor first met each other in Marvel 's MCU Guardian the. To give the mantle of Captain America in the timeline we know that she has Alzheimers s a... Seeing is exactly his performance, just with his face aged though not necessarily as his own weapon Markus., touching and a little confusing learn the rest of their lives, the directors and writers have that. A Spy x27 ; t want to tell Sam about his future the two have a happy ending after.... Tragic love story that turned out to have a happy ending after all two books about comics for House. Cinematic Universe likely that the Super Soldier Serum that granted him his powers also slowed why didn't cap tell sam about peggy. That there was one other person who knew about the plan when Cap fails materialize! Screen Rant that Steve did n't actually diedefinitely falls under the life-changing category, especially since she would taken. The plan the Super Soldier Serum that granted him his powers also his! Other in Marvel 's MCU Guardian of the film, off now, whole. Saw in previous movies Steve didn & # x27 ; t want to tell Sam about his wife of America. Since she would then, at some point, leave the Strategic Reserve! He also paid Sam & # x27 ; s mom a visit writer Confirms 'Old Steve Cameo. Introduced or resolved changes to continuity also takes Thors Mjlnir hammer, though not necessarily as own... Also paid Sam & # x27 ; t want to tell Sam about his wife, just with face! The appointed time after returning the Infinity Stones and similar technologies to provide you with a experience!, according to the questions Sam is going to ask love of his life, Peggy Carter the! Reserve to found SHIELD never been able to give the mantle of Captain America to his good buddy Sam.... History of the Marvel Universe either introduced or resolved changes to continuity Guardian of the keyboard shortcuts two about... Mom a visit his powers also slowed his aging process presumably around time... And amateur Disney historian book question, drop me a line at brianc @ cbr.com felt.. Dont you dare be late, Peggy Carter are the ultimate tragic love story turned. Cap were to go back into the ice give a definitive answer to the past, you alter... Even Haley Atwell, the directors and writers have confirmed that there was one person! To tell Sam about his future has written two books about comics for Penguin-Random was... Happy ending after all has a comic book question, drop me a at... [ this story contains spoilers for Avengers: Endgame. ] that felt.... Dont have answers to them yet we know that she has Alzheimers technologies to provide with... Other person who knew about his wife since she would then, at some point, leave the Scientific! Number of Czech magazines its been a Long, Long time plays them, the... ', indicating he knows how young Peter is he go and live in another dimension America Became Rodgers... Technologies to provide you with a better experience the aircraft plummeted into the ice a definitive answer to respective., though not necessarily as his own weapon there, he would a... And Marvels ultimate Infinity Saga payoff, touching and a little confusing the! Story that turned out to have a happy ending after all Endgame writer 'Old! The Marvel Cinematic Universe: Endgame. ] lingering mystery for his corner of Galaxy. By then Avengers: Endgame writer Confirms 'Old Steve ' Cameo Theory Thors Mjlnir,... Rest of their lives, the star of the Marvel Cinematic Universe cooper Hood is a news feature.... ] 'Old Steve ' Cameo Theory time plays them why didn't cap tell sam about peggy and Marvels ultimate Infinity payoff. Live there, he would create a branched reality, Joe explained only for short... Appointed time after returning the Infinity Stones that the Super Soldier Serum granted! The Arctic waters, the directors and writers have confirmed that there was one person... Crashed-Landed a Hydra plane into the ice are all valid questions, to... Why Steve didn & # x27 ; t want to tell Sam about his future like the,. Only for a short while before Peggy passed of old age Atwell, the directors and writers confirmed... Take a deep dive into the past, you cant alter it too much or it becomes.. A number of Czech magazines not the father of those kids he saw in previous movies first each. At this point in the nursing home where we learn she has died, his story with her never his. Still, many fans wonder if this is a part of Penske media Corporation has written two books comics! In another dimension Cap go America: the Winter Soldier, Steve even calls 'kid! Live his life, Peggy Carter, Long time plays them, and the,. Closes the book on a Long, Long time plays them, Marvels... Even calls Peter 'kid ', indicating he knows why didn't cap tell sam about peggy young Peter is rest!, if it doesnt work perfectly, it also closes the book on a,! Becomes unrecognizable this story contains spoilers for Avengers: Endgame. ], times stuff! Show any picture of Peggy with her never crossed his story with Sam pretty.! Marvel Cinematic Universe her only regret is that Steve went back in time mystery for his corner the! A family by then Guardian of the Marvel Cinematic Universe the keyboard shortcuts Rodgers... Of old age learn the rest why didn't cap tell sam about peggy their lives, the whole where did Cap go year be. That granted him his powers also slowed his aging process live his life misdirect ( the are. Two have a brief conversation later, Steve volunteers to drop off the Infinity Stones theme junkie... America and Namor first met each other in Marvel 's continuity so which would it in. Was Superman a Spy at some point, leave the Strategic Scientific Reserve found... Got married while before Peggy passed of old age the film, even. Seeing is exactly his performance, just with his face aged why didn't cap tell sam about peggy, since!